At the Paris
Peace Conference in 1919 after the end of formal fighting in World War One,
Britain and France, over the objection of the United States, forced Germany to
accept a war guilt clause. This clause
put the complete responsibility for dragging Europe into the war in 1914 on
Germany, forcing the state to accept draconian punishments. These included complete disarmament,
significant land concessions, and substantial war reparations. While the German delegation had little choice
but to sign it, the reality is that Germany did not prove to be the state most
at fault for the descent into war.
After the Habsburg heir to the Austro-Hungarian
throne, Franz Ferdinand, and his wife were assassinated in Sarajevo by Serbian
freedom fighters, the Dual Monarchy understandably was enraged with its small
satellite state. They issued Serbia with
a list of demands—an ultimatum—which the small country had to meet to avoid a
war. One of these demands was a joint
investigation into the assassination to determine responsibility. The Serbian government, however, was
unwilling to agree to such an investigation due to the prior knowledge some
high-ranking governmental officials had of the assassination.
Serbia, fearful of an Austrian
invasion, turned to its regional ally, the Russian Empire, for assistance. Since the two states shared a common
history—both are Slavic people—Serbia was nearly certain that Russian assistance
would be provided. Wishing to avoid another
Balkan war, Serbia hoped that by bringing Russia into the equation
Austria-Hungary would back off from its bellicose position and allow cooler
heads to prevail.
Austria-Hungary, however, was not in
a particularly peaceful state of mind and had not been even before Ferdinand
was assassinated. Tired of its Southern
Balkan satellite states resisting its control, many high Austro-Hungarian
officials desired a regional war to straighten the problem out. Ferdinand had provided a prominent voice for
a peaceful and negotiated settlement; but after his assassination, there was no
Habsburg voice—at least no strong voice—for peace. Additionally, with the spread of nationalism
threatening the multinational empire, many government officials believed that a
war would strengthen the monarchy and the people’s ties to it, thus preserving
the old ways for more years.
While thus far Germany was not
involved in the process at all, the empire was soon brought into the equation
when the Austro-Hungarian Empire asked for support for their planned invasion
of Serbia. In what would be a focal
point of the German blame assignment post-war, Germany gave Austria-Hungary the
famous “blank check” of support. This
was a calculated risk by the German government; a risk which quite literally
blew up in its face. Kaiser Wilhelm
believed that the local war which Austria-Hungary sought was possible, in which
case the “blank check” would not have to be cashed. While the state could have chosen to play a
peacemaking role, the empire believed that the Habsburgs could win a quick
regional war which would not only pose no threat to German security but also
bolster the strength—both internally and externally—of its primary ally. These calculations and assumptions were
dashed when Russia answered the Serbian cry for help.
The Russian Empire, always a few
steps behind the rest of the European continent, desired to increase its
influence in Eastern Europe, the Balkans in particular, in its never-ending
quest for a warm water seaport. As such,
they eagerly answered Serbia’s call for two additional reasons. First, the empire had been embarrassed a
decade earlier in the Sino-Russo War and sought to repair its international
reputation by protecting Serbia. Second,
as revolutions were shaking the foundations of the monarchy, the government
believed that a war—particularly one to rescue an ethnic sibling—would
reinspire domestic faith in the empire.
As such, the military quickly mobilized its military against both
Austria-Hungary and Germany, as its mobilization plan called for, despite
Germany’s minuscule role in the affair.
Thus, once Austria-Hungary invaded
Serbia, Russia invaded both Austria-Hungary and Germany, which required Britain
and France to mobilize against Germany as well.
While Germany’s support for its ally certainly played a role in the
outbreak of the war, the assertion that “Germany bears principle responsibility
for Europe’s descent into war in 1914” is incorrect. No party was thinking clearly, as all seemed
to disregard the alliance system which created the domino effect of cascading
war. Instead, the brunt of the blame
should belong to Austria-Hungary and Russia.
Austria-Hungary for seeking to thoroughly punish Serbia more than was
necessary, and Russia for its over eagerness to repair its international
reputation by military intervention in a regional conflict. Additionally, both states foolishly believed
that a war, regardless of scale, would help to preserve their crumbling
monarchies. Germany played a role, but
to a much smaller degree than the egos of both Vienna and Moscow.
No comments:
Post a Comment